Grace has medical procedure that leaves her with a sore on her lip and when she runs into her new boyfriend she does her best to avoid him but decides to come clean. He also does the same, by telling her he has 6 toes on one of his feet. And when they spend some time alone, he decides to take his shoe off and she becomes uncomfortable. Will and Jack discover that they're seeing the same guy who was unaware of their connection. So they decide to both bow out but the guy keeps calling Will, and Grace convinces him that Jack will understand.